Last updated September 21, 2026
Eiger 1936 Disaster: The Hinterstoisser Tragedy
In July 1936, Andreas “Anderl” Hinterstoisser and Toni Kurz of Germany joined Austrian climbers Willy Angerer and Edi Rainer for an attempt on the still-unclimbed central North Face of the Eiger. Hinterstoisser solved the blank slab that now bears his name, but the party retrieved the traverse rope after crossing. When Angerer was injured and the weather collapsed, the four turned back—and could not reverse the iced traverse. Their forced descent ended in catastrophe. Hinterstoisser, Angerer and Rainer died first. Kurz survived alone on the wall long enough for Swiss guides to come within metres of him, only to die when a knot in the rescue rope jammed during his final rappel.
What happened on the Eiger in 1936?
The four-man German-Austrian party climbed rapidly into the Eiger North Face on July 18, 1936. Hinterstoisser pioneered an ingenious tension traverse across a smooth slab, but the rope used to cross was retrieved. Bad weather, rockfall and an injury to Willy Angerer forced the team to retreat. By then the traverse was iced and could not be reversed. The climbers tried to descend directly by rope. During the final crisis Hinterstoisser fell, Angerer and Rainer were killed while still attached to the system, and Toni Kurz remained alive. Swiss guides reached the face from a Jungfrau Railway gallery and spent hours trying to save him. Kurz eventually rappelled to within a few metres of them, but the knot joining two rescue ropes jammed at his carabiner. Exhausted and severely frostbitten, he died before they could reach him.
The Disaster That Turned the Nordwand Into Legend
The Eiger’s North Face had already killed two climbers in 1935. The 1936 tragedy was different: much of it unfolded in sight of observers and railway workers, and one climber remained alive long enough for an extraordinary rescue attempt.
The Eiger North Face Rises Directly Above Kleine Scheidegg
The geography made the tragedy unusually visible. The Jungfrau Railway tunnels through the mountain, and gallery openings in the North Face gave rescuers an access point impossible on most great walls. Below, observers at Kleine Scheidegg followed the climbers through telescopes whenever cloud allowed.
1936 orientation
The modern Swiss Alpine Club elevation is 3,967 m; older 1930s sources used slightly different mapped elevations.
Hinterstoisser Traverse, Death Bivouac, White Spider: A Face Mapped by Tragedy
Many of the names that define the classic Eiger route came from the failed attempts of the 1930s. The 1936 team never reached the upper features of the eventual Heckmair Route, but its key lower traverse still carries Hinterstoisser’s name.
The Central North Face Was Still One of the Alps’ Great Unsolved Problems
The summit of the Eiger had been reached from easier sides since 1858. The central North Face was another category entirely: a concave wall exposed to stonefall, icefall, avalanches and fast weather change.
Sedlmayr and Mehringer died
Max Sedlmayr and Karl Mehringer were caught high on the face during the previous year’s serious attempt.
Their final bivouac gave “Death Bivouac” its name.The Alps were in unusually bad shape
The contemporary Alpine Journal described heavy snow, poor weather and dangerous conditions across the Bernese Oberland.
Several other prospective Eiger parties abandoned their plans.The wall was visible from below
Railways, hotels and telescopes made the Eiger a vertical arena unlike remote Alpine faces.
Success or disaster could become public spectacle in real time.The Four Climbers of the 1936 Attempt
They began as German and Austrian partnerships but worked together on the face. Contemporary sources describe all four as young climbers in their twenties; later histories emphasize the technical strength of Hinterstoisser and Kurz in particular.
The Eiger’s Lower Ice Fields Concentrate Rock, Ice and Avalanche Exposure
This 1979 photograph is not the 1936 party. It shows the kind of mixed rock-and-ice environment that slowed the retreat after weather and injury changed the team’s objective from ascent to survival.
What Was the Hinterstoisser Traverse?
Hinterstoisser solved a smooth, exposed slab by using a tension traverse: he climbed into position, used the rope for lateral support and established a line that allowed the other three climbers to cross. The solution was brilliant—but reversible only if the rope remained available.
Why couldn’t they simply reverse it?
By the retreat, weather had glazed the slab with ice. The original move depended on having a tensioning system established from the ascent side. Recreating it in reverse from the wrong side, while exhausted and managing an injured climber, proved impossible.
The Eiger 1936 Disaster: Day by Day
The 1936 Alpine Journal provides a near-contemporary chronology. Its editorial language was strongly judgmental; the timeline below uses the factual sequence without adopting that rhetoric.
The four entered the face at about 2 a.m.
They moved fast, reaching roughly 3,000 m by morning. Hinterstoisser completed the crucial traverse and the party continued toward the First Ice Field and Rote Fluh area.
They climbed into worsening weather
The contemporary account records thunder, lightning, flowing water and snow slides. The party bivouacked around 3,200 m.
Cloud repeatedly swallowed the face
Observers saw the climbers moving upward during a brief clearing before visibility closed again.
The team turned around
Through gaps in the cloud, observers saw the party descending. Angerer—or in some early reports possibly Rainer—appeared to have a head or upper-body injury. Later histories identify Angerer as the seriously injured climber.
The retreat reached the lower barrier
The party could not re-establish the now-iced traverse. They attempted to move upward and sideways toward the Rote Fluh, then resorted to a direct rope descent.
Swiss guides entered the face
Adolf and Christian Rubi, Hans Schlunegger and Arnold Glatthard used a railway gallery to approach the stranded climbers under constant stonefall and snow slides.
Three climbers died; Kurz remained alive
The exact mechanics were reconstructed from guides, telescope observations and Kurz’s shouted account. Hinterstoisser fell; Angerer and Rainer died while still connected to the rope system; Kurz remained suspended and frostbitten.
Kurz almost reached the rescuers
After hours of rope work with a frozen arm and hand, he began rappelling toward the guides. The joining knot in the rescue rope jammed at his carabiner only metres above them. He died around 11:30 a.m.
A Tunnel Window Put Guides Inside the Wall
The Jungfrau Railway’s gallery opening gave Swiss guides a way to enter the North Face laterally. Without that unusual infrastructure, rescuers could not have come anywhere near Toni Kurz in the storm.
Why Did the Retreat Fail?
The disaster is often reduced to “they pulled the rope.” That is true but incomplete. Several problems had converged by the time the team tried to reverse the lower face.
Angerer was compromised
Rockfall had injured him and slowed the party.
Retreat speed and rope management became harder.The face had changed
Rain, snow, freezing conditions and avalanche activity turned rock moves into glazed terrain.
The line they climbed was not the line they returned to.The fixed crossing was gone
The rope used to solve the Hinterstoisser Traverse had been retrieved.
The key move could not simply be reversed.Direct descent entered worse terrain
Blocked from reversing the normal line, the team was forced toward a steep, overhanging descent.
Rope length and anchor geometry became critical.Multiple nights had accumulated
The team had already endured repeated bivouacs in poor conditions.
Cold, hunger and fatigue narrowed every margin.Help could get close, not reach them
Even professional guides entering from the railway gallery were stopped by iced, overhanging terrain.
Proximity was not the same as access.How Did Hinterstoisser, Angerer and Rainer Die?
No surviving climber witnessed the full sequence from a stable position. The 1936 account itself says the exact event could not be known and reconstructed it from the guides, telescope observations and Kurz’s shouts. Later histories often simplify the event as an avalanche striking the rope team.
| Climber | Best-supported reconstruction | Confidence |
|---|---|---|
| Andreas Hinterstoisser | He detached from the rope arrangement while the team tried to extend the descent and fell from the face during the crisis. Later retellings commonly place an avalanche at the start of the chain event. | High that he fell free; lower on the exact trigger second by second. |
| Willy Angerer | Already injured, he was caught in the rope system during the fall and died from traumatic injury / constriction while suspended. | High that he died in the rope system; details vary by account. |
| Edi Rainer | He was crushed or constricted against the anchor/piton system by the loaded rope and died soon afterward. | Moderate to high; reconstructed rather than directly witnessed. |
| Toni Kurz | He survived the initial fatal sequence, remained attached near his dead companions, and communicated with the guides below. | High; rescue guides spoke with him directly. |
Why wording matters
“An avalanche killed all four” is too simple. The weather and snow slides created the crisis, but different members died through different mechanisms within a loaded rope system. Kurz survived the initial event for many hours.
Toni Kurz Could Hear the Guides Below Him
The cruelty of the rescue is why this accident remains so powerful: Kurz was not lost somewhere unseen. He was alive, communicating, and eventually almost within reach—yet the geometry of the wall and the rope system kept the rescuers from touching him.
How Close Did the Guides Get to Toni Kurz?
The contemporary Alpine Journal says the guides were stopped roughly 150 ft from Kurz by vertical, ice-glazed rock. They could communicate but could not climb directly to him.
The first rescue push could not close the gap
Guides crossed the face from the railway gallery under stonefall and snow slides. Darkness and conditions eventually forced them to retreat for the night.
The guides returned
They again reached the closest feasible position below Kurz but could not cross the final glazed vertical section.
Kurz cut loose the dead weight below him
Following instructions, he severed the rope connecting him to Angerer’s body, freeing enough rope to begin building a retrieval system.
He created a thin cord from the climbing rope
With one arm and hand badly frostbitten, Kurz laboriously separated rope strands and knotted lengths together so he could lower a line to the guides.
The guides attached two shorter ropes
Their combined rope, hardware and anchor equipment were hauled back up by Kurz so he could construct a rappel system.
Kurz rappelled toward the rescuers
Another snow slide hit during the process, but he continued. Arnold Glatthard eventually stood on another guide’s shoulders and came close enough to nearly touch Kurz’s crampons with an ice axe.
The joining knot jammed
The knot connecting the rescue ropes would not pass through Kurz’s carabiner arrangement. Too exhausted to reverse the system or solve the jam, he died suspended just beyond reach.
Why Did the Rope Knot Stop Toni Kurz?
The guides’ available rope had to be extended by joining lengths together. Kurz hauled the combined line up and rigged it through a carabiner for his descent. That created a mechanical problem: the connection knot was larger than the opening/path through which the rope needed to move.
As Kurz descended, the knot reached the carabiner and stopped. He was hanging free enough that he could not simply stand on the rock and unload the system. By then he had been exposed for days, one arm and hand were largely unusable from frostbite, and the rope work itself had consumed hours.
The rescuers were not “one easy pull” away.
They were separated by a vertical, glazed section they could not climb. One guide standing on another’s shoulders could only nearly reach Kurz’s crampon with an ice axe. The remaining distance was physically small and technically decisive.
What the 1936 Eiger Record Actually Supports
The tragedy has been retold in books, documentaries and films. Some details are well documented; others became cleaner or more dramatic with repetition.
| Claim | Verdict | What the sources support |
|---|---|---|
| “The team died because Hinterstoisser removed the traverse rope.” | Partly true, too simple | Removing the rope made retreat across the iced traverse impossible, but injury, weather, exposure, rope length and the forced direct descent all contributed. |
| “An avalanche killed all four climbers at once.” | False as stated | The fatal sequence involved snow/avalanche activity and rope-system failures, but Kurz survived the initial event and the others died by different mechanisms. |
| “Toni Kurz died only a few feet from rescuers.” | Essentially true | The guides came extraordinarily close but were separated by unclimbable glazed terrain; they could nearly touch his crampons with an ice axe. |
| “The knot killed Kurz.” | Mechanically true, medically incomplete | The jam stopped the rappel, but Kurz was already critically exhausted, cold and frostbitten after days on the wall. |
| “His last words were ‘Ich kann nicht mehr.’” | Widely attributed | Later accounts preserve the phrase “I can’t go on anymore.” The near-contemporary 1936 Alpine Journal describes his death but does not record that exact quotation. |
| “The North Face was first climbed in 1936.” | False | The central Nordwand remained unclimbed until Heckmair, Vörg, Harrer and Kasparek succeeded in 1938. |
The 1938 First Ascensionists Climbed With the Failed Attempts Behind Them
Anderl Heckmair later wrote that he studied the attempts of earlier climbers and used what they had learned. The successful 1938 party did not approach the North Face as an unknown wall.
How the 1936 Tragedy Shaped the First Ascent
Heckmair’s later writing makes the connection explicit: the failed attempts of the mid-1930s created knowledge about route finding, conditions and retreat that informed the successful climb.
The traverse remained the lower key
The Hinterstoisser Traverse became a named obstacle on the route that eventually succeeded.
Later teams treated it as a strategic passage, not an improvised surprise.Leaving a return system mattered
The 1936 experience showed that a passage solved in one direction can become a trap if it cannot be reversed.
Retreat architecture became part of the route plan.The wall had to be read as a system
Rockfall, meltwater, ice and storm could transform the same pitch within hours.
Speed alone could not replace a stable weather window.Rebitsch and Vörg retreated alive
A serious 1937 party turned back from high on the face and became the first to survive a major retreat from the central wall.
The mountain was slowly teaching climbers how to escape it.Heckmair Route completed
Anderl Heckmair, Ludwig Vörg, Heinrich Harrer and Fritz Kasparek finally climbed the central North Face.
The route absorbed lessons from the tragedies before it.Kurz became the human face of the Nordwand
His prolonged rescue struggle transformed an alpine accident into one of mountaineering’s best-known survival stories.
The rescue, more than the summit attempt, explains the disaster’s lasting hold.The Eiger North Face Is Still an Extreme Alpine Objective
The Swiss Alpine Club currently lists the Eiger at 3,967 m. Its route archive grades the classic North Face / Heckmair line AS V+ and notes that the route is now climbed almost exclusively in the winter half of the year.
| Feature | 1936 attempt | Modern classic North Face |
|---|---|---|
| Face status | Unclimbed central wall | Established Heckmair Route with extensive accumulated route knowledge |
| Traverse | Hinterstoisser solved by improvised tension traverse | Known named obstacle on the classic line |
| Forecasting | Limited regional weather information | Modern forecasts, webcams and communication—but conditions still control the route |
| Rescue | Guides on foot from railway gallery | Modern rescue systems, yet weather and terrain can still prevent access |
| SAC framing | No modern grade system | Classic Nordwand route listed in the route archive at AS V+ |
| Season pattern | Summer attempt | SAC says the classic line is now climbed almost exclusively in the winter half-year |
The 1936 Tragedy Helped Create the “Murder Wall” Reputation
Global Summit Guide’s current Eiger Death Rate analysis places the North Face toll at roughly 64 deaths since serious attempts began in the 1930s, while warning that historical counts vary by source and period. The four deaths in 1936 are central to that history—but they should not be treated as a modern personal probability for an expert climber on a different route or in different conditions.
The important statistic is concentrated hazard, not raw body count.
The Nordwand has far fewer deaths than mass-participation mountains, but it concentrates rockfall, icefall, avalanche, weather and technical retreat problems into a wall attempted by a small, highly experienced population.
Direct Answers to the Questions Searchers Ask Most
Where the reconstruction is uncertain, the answer says so rather than repeating a cleaner legend.
Who died in the 1936 Eiger disaster?
Andreas “Anderl” Hinterstoisser, Toni Kurz, Willy Angerer and Eduard “Edi” Rainer all died during the July 1936 attempt on the Eiger North Face.
What was the Hinterstoisser Traverse?
It was a difficult exposed traverse across a smooth slab on the lower North Face. Hinterstoisser solved it using a tension-traverse technique and established a rope for his partners. The rope was then retrieved, leaving no fixed return line.
Why couldn’t the climbers reverse the Hinterstoisser Traverse?
During the retreat the slab had become iced by bad weather. Recreating the original tension traverse from the opposite side while exhausted and managing an injured climber proved impossible.
Why did the 1936 Eiger team turn back?
Bad weather, deteriorating conditions and a serious injury to Willy Angerer forced the party to abandon the summit attempt and descend.
How did Andreas Hinterstoisser die?
The exact second-by-second sequence was reconstructed rather than directly witnessed. The contemporary account says Hinterstoisser detached from the rope arrangement during the direct descent and fell from the face during the crisis, while later retellings commonly describe avalanche activity as the trigger.
How did Toni Kurz survive the initial disaster?
Kurz remained secured in the rope system after Hinterstoisser fell and Angerer and Rainer died. He was able to communicate with Swiss guides below, although one arm and hand became severely frostbitten.
Why couldn’t rescuers reach Toni Kurz?
Vertical, ice-glazed terrain separated Kurz from the guides approaching from the railway gallery. They came very close but could not climb the final section safely.
Why did the knot stop Toni Kurz?
The rescue line had been lengthened by tying ropes together. During Kurz’s rappel, that joining knot reached his carabiner system and could not pass through it, stopping him several metres above the guides.
What were Toni Kurz’s last words?
The phrase widely attributed to him is “Ich kann nicht mehr,” meaning “I can’t go on anymore.” Later histories preserve the phrase, but the near-contemporary 1936 Alpine Journal account does not record those exact words.
When was the Eiger North Face first climbed?
The central North Face was first climbed in July 1938 by Anderl Heckmair, Ludwig Vörg, Heinrich Harrer and Fritz Kasparek.
Is the Hinterstoisser Traverse still part of the Eiger route?
Yes. It remains one of the named landmarks of the classic North Face / Heckmair Route, though modern equipment and accumulated route knowledge are radically different from 1936.
Why is the 1936 Eiger tragedy so famous?
The disaster combined a major unsolved Alpine wall, public observation from Kleine Scheidegg, the unusual railway access used by rescuers and Toni Kurz’s prolonged survival only metres beyond rescue. It became one of the defining stories of twentieth-century alpinism.
The 1936 Record Is Detailed—but Not Neutral
The near-contemporary Alpine Journal report is invaluable for chronology and rescue detail, but its editorial commentary reflects the attitudes and politics of its era. This page uses its factual reporting while avoiding its moral judgments about the climbers.
The Brilliant Move That Opened the Route Also Closed the Way Home.
The Hinterstoisser Traverse is remembered because it captures the whole tragedy in one feature. On the ascent, it was an elegant technical solution. On the retreat, after the rope had been removed and the slab had iced over, it became a locked door. Yet the disaster was larger than one rope decision: injury, storm, avalanche activity, fatigue, direct descent, rescue geometry and primitive equipment all converged. Toni Kurz’s final hours made the story immortal—but the deeper mountaineering lesson is simpler: every committed move upward must be judged against how the team will get back down if the mountain changes.
Was this helpful?
🏔Related peaks nearby
🧭Explore & compare
Global Summit Guide is an independent mountaineering resource founded in 2026. The team combines first-hand trekking and climbing experience with in-depth research and professional health and nutrition review to help climbers choose objectives, prepare properly, and stay safe.
Health, altitude, and nutrition content is reviewed by Taylor Ludlow (Registered Nurse) and Brigg Hoopes (Nutritionist).
What We Don't Know Yet
Mountain information changes quickly. This box explains the limits of what this page can responsibly promise.
- Visa, passport, vaccination, border, insurance, and local transportation rules may change before your trip.
- Route conditions, snowpack, closures, and weather can change quickly after this page is updated.
- Permit rules, fees, quotas, and reservation windows may change between review cycles.
- Operator availability, pricing, guide ratios, and cancellation terms can change by season.
- Your fitness, altitude response, risk tolerance, and experience level may change what is safe or realistic.
Verify current conditions with official land managers, guide services, local forecasts, and current route reports before booking or climbing.
Mountaineering, rock and ice climbing, glacier travel, and high-altitude activity are inherently dangerous and can result in serious injury or death. The information on Global Summit Guide is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional instruction, qualified guiding, proper equipment, or your own judgment and experience.
Route conditions, weather, snowpack, permits, regulations, and hazards change constantly and may differ from what is described here. Details may be incomplete, out of date, or contain errors. Always verify current information with local authorities, certified guides, and official sources before making any decision in the mountains.
Nothing on this site is medical, legal, or financial advice. Our fitness, acclimatization, altitude, and nutrition content is general in nature; consult a qualified physician before beginning any strenuous exercise program or exposing yourself to high altitude.
You are solely responsible for your own safety and decisions. To the fullest extent permitted by law, Global Summit Guide and its team accept no liability for any loss, injury, damage, or expense arising from use of, or reliance on, this information. By using this site you acknowledge these risks and accept these terms.
Some links on this site may be affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you; this never affects our recommendations.
Global Summit Guide recommendation path
Next Best Mountain to Research
Use these recommendations to continue the right planning path instead of stopping on one page.
Use current permit, weather, route, and operator information before booking or climbing.